Saturday, 29 January 2011
Death and transfiguration
I love dance; I love to dance. Salsa is my dance of choice, something I do rather well, considering I only took it up a few years ago. When I was little it was ballet. I took lessons from the age of five onwards, passing through the various grades, right up to the time just before I went to prep school. Yes, I wanted to be a ballerina, every little girl’s dream. In the end I realised that I did not have the commitment, I did not have the ambition and I did not have an obsession with perfection.
Perfection, that’s what Black Swan is about, the relentless pursuit of perfection, perfection for oneself, perfection for others. This is not a great movie - there are too many clichés concerning female sexuality, psychological frigidity and breakdown for that - but it’s bold, stylish, visually seductive and highly engaging. Above all it's worth seeing for the performance of Natalie Portman, a pirouette of perfection. I don’t like making predictions –I’m invariably wrong! – but I’m guessing that she will win the Oscar for Best Actress, just as Colin Firth will win Best Actor for his part in The King’s Speech. So place your bets now!
I’m dancing too fast. Let me just pause and say that Black Swan, directed by Darren Aronofsky, is a film set around a New York ballet company’s fresh staging of Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake. Thomas Leroy, the imperious and slightly seedy artistic director, played by Vincent Cassel, as well as planning a novel and starker production is also looking for a new swan to replace Beth Macintyre, the company’s fading and aging star, a brilliant cameo performance by Winona Ryder, echoes, one suspects, of real life. He alights on Nina Sayers (Portman), a dancer who has all of the technical accomplishment to take on a demanding part.
There is only one problem: Nina can play the virginal White Swan, indeed she might be said to have been born for the part, but there is a dark underside – for she also has to take on the role of her evil twin, the Black Swan. Leroy’s principle concern is that his new protégé lacks enough experience of life, enough sensual experience, to play the Black Swan. Here she has to do more than dance; she has to sizzle. To help her ‘loosen up’ he sets masturbation as a homework assignment!
The whole movie is about dualities, about white and black, about good and evil, about doppelgangers, real and imagined. Nina is a vulnerable character to begin with, made more vulnerable in pursuit of darkness, the shadows in her own mind. It’s particularly difficult for her because her experience of real life is almost non-existent. She has emotional and psychological problems, caused not just by her own obsessions, obsessions which steadily turn into nightmares, but by the usual suspect – mummy!
Nina, you see, lives at home with her mother, a single parent, a super performance by Barbara Hershey, chilly, manipulative and controlling. She herself was a dancer, though one who never emerged from the corps de ballet. She is clearly living vicariously through Nina, whom she keeps in a cocoon of childhood, a substitute for her own failures and inadequacies. There is also a slight undercurrent, one suspects, of resentment and jealousy.
Into this complex mix Leroy introduces a new dancer, Lily, brilliantly played by Mila Kunis. What Lily lacks in technique she makes up for in emotional sensuality and experience of life. Here, now, is the central tension of the movie, a fresh duality. Nina is both threatened by Lily and attracted to Lily. Why is she there? Is she a friend or an enemy? Is she attempting to undermine Nina, to replace her? Is Leroy using her as part of plan to make Nina less frigid, less virginal? She is eventually selected as an alternate, though if this is to encourage or to sidestep Nina is uncertain. The ambiguities here are never fully resolved.
Nina both rises to the challenge while descending deeper into isolation and madness, all accompanied by ever more alarming hallucinations. In some ways the movie is difficult to pinpoint in terms of genre. It’s billed as a psychological thriller or as psychological horror. There are certainly elements of both, a distinct gothic veneer with some pronounced creepy moments. I was reminded at points of Suspira, one of my all-time favourite movies, which also happens to be set against the background of dance. If I tell you that Aronofsky lists his influences as Roman Polanski’s Repulsion and Fyodor Dostoevsky’s novella The Double, then you may very well grasp both the approach and the implied ambiguity. There are also slight David Cronenberg overtones, the sort of gross body alterations that one associates with this director!
But I read Black Swan more simply as a story of paranoia and breakdown, of delusions heightened by the pressures of reality, by betrayals real and imagined. I cannot say just how impressed I was by Portman, an actress I’ve never previously rated very highly. When she finally appears on stage as the Black Swan, having discovered her dark side - by what process I am not going to reveal – I was completely overwhelmed along with the audience in the theatre. That scene, those moments, were the highlight of the whole movie, only equalled by her death – literal – as the deceived and betrayed White Swan. This is death and transfiguration; in the end, as she says, she attained perfection.
Posted by Anastasia F-B at 17:45
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
I used to know some dancers when I lived in London. It's the toughest end of showbiz.ReplyDelete
I saw it one hour ago and I like it, i think is a very good job, all actors were great, Portman is excepional, i like your review, very clever, good points about perfection and the resolution of "a story of paranoia and breakdown", the girl was in madness with her own personality, she become the two sides of the work in the theater, she assume her role of the queen swan. What a great moment that I passed watching this movie!. A kiss. Mario.ReplyDelete
Keep on dancing, it stirs the blood. I have not seen this film ,but it seems like a self-realization girly movie.ReplyDelete
Calvin, it most certainly is, lots of hard work and a relatively short career lifespan, the profession of the butterfly. Incidentally, the ballet community is up in arms over the way they have been depicted here, as a lot of compulsive neurotics. It always makes me smile when people react like this, somehow dissolving the boundaries between fiction and reality. Did hoteliers get angry over Psycho I wonder? :-)ReplyDelete
Mario, I saw it yesterday evening in London before going on for drinks with friends. But I was so full of the movie that I dashed off this review as soon as I got back, which was almost one o’clock in the morning!ReplyDelete
Dear Anthony, I shall. Yes, it is a ‘chick flick’ in some ways though there is plenty to keep the guys interested, including some girl on girl action, if you are in to that sort of thing. :-)ReplyDelete
I have not seen this movie yet...but, your post has convinced me I must.ReplyDelete
We are fortunate, we who do not have to descend into darkness ourselves, but can learn from the great artists and writers, and real monsters like The Dwarf what it is that hides there. I am a child of 75 years, but still a student of this impenetrable mystery in which we are all locked. I remain your student.
Anthony, oh, I see. Typical guy!ReplyDelete
Count Sneaky, I am truly honoured. Sometimes I think I can be just a tad too arrogant; that it will take a lifetime to unlearn what I have learned. :-)ReplyDelete
This comment has been removed by the author.ReplyDelete
Pretty much,but that was then and this is now.You will find that in many cases the desire (lust) and accompanying fantasies are far better than the actual attainment.ReplyDelete
Yes, I'm sure. :-)ReplyDelete
Thanks, I'll have to watch it now.ReplyDelete
Do please let me know what you think.ReplyDelete
just watched this movie! see how slow i am!ReplyDelete
great review ana. my favorite line:
"The whole movie is about dualities, about white and black, about good and evil, about doppelgangers, real and imagined. " this is a brilliant summary of movie! and i am more surprised to read your final paragraph, i did not know she died! or you just made it up?
No, not at all. :-)ReplyDelete